The National’s Top Five ‘Cincinnati Nights’ Records

The National have always seemed to be cut from the same cloth as Bruce Springsteen — the arc of critical acclaim (and modest sales) through their first three albums alongside the blue-collar determination of touring. With the release of 2007’s Boxer, The National landed in the ears of everyone on the planet with an album that Pitchfork named “Best New Music” when that christening could make or break an artist. Boxer, along with 2010’s High Violet and 2013’s Trouble Will Find Me, should be atop everyone’s indie rock primer alongside Radiohead, Arcade Fire, and Interpol.

Fast forward 12 years, and The National have graduated to bonafide festival headliners — who even curate their own fests! They just released the latest in a string of acclaimed records, I Am Easy To Find.

Below, The National’s frontman Matt Berninger dives into the city of their birth, Cincinnati. Matt’s theme of Cincinnati Nights is a perfect look into Cincinnati when The Breeders and Afghan Whigs ruled the world.

Matt Berninger’s Top Five Albums From His Cincinnati Nights

Ohio in the early ’90s had a very intense and intimidating rock scene. I was in my twenties and going to every rock show in Cincinnati and Dayton that I could. Around this time is when I met Scott and we started the band Nancy with Casey Reas and Mike Brewer. Members of Brainiac came to see us play once in Casey’s basement and left after two songs. Meanwhile, Bryan and the Dessners had a different band balled Project Nim that was this academic hippy thing.

These are some of the bands we would see around town and then suddenly in magazines and on MTV. We realized that Seattle was dying and everything cool was coming out of our neighborhood now. But we weren’t really in the scene, just fans and students of it all. Bryan literally took lessons from the Afghan Whigs’ first drummer. Another completely different kind of scene happened around us later in New York.

The National's top 5 Cincinnati records: Afghan Whigs - Congregation

1. Afghan Whigs – Congregation

It’s hard to separate listening to this record from seeing them live at Bogart’s on Short Vine. They were terrifying and sexy and fucked up and they were from our town. The cover with the naked black woman holding the white baby was pretty intense in Cincinnati. These guys were complicated and serious. At one show Greg Dulli spit his cigarette at the crowd as he launched into the opening riff of ‘I’m Her Slave’ and it hit this girl next to me in the face. To me, these guys made the grunge scene in Seattle seem kinda like a bunch of dumb stoners.

The National's top 5 Cincinnati records: Brainiac - Bonzai Superstar

2. Brainiac – Bonsai Superstar

Seeing this band perform was something that would re-wire your idea of a rock band. They were doing things both musically and performance-wise that seemed entirely free and unburdened by self-consciousness and insecurity. And it was organic and honest and fearless and unhinged. They were channeling something very healing and potent. They were way out on a strange limb all by themselves.

The National's top 5 Cincinnati records: The Breeders - Pod

3. The Breeders – Pod

There was a black and white photo of Kim Deal in a flannel shirt buttoned all the way up that I was in love with. The Pixies were the coolest band on the planet and she lived 45 minutes away. And here’s this other band she has with her twin sister, and the cover is a naked Vaughn Oliver wearing a huge eel as a dick. The Breeders are badass and brilliant and singular.

The National's top 5 Cincinnati records: Guided By Voices - Bee Thousand

4. Guided By Voices – Bee Thousand

A school teacher with a shitty attitude and a drinking problem makes records for years in his garage with his pals, and they’re brilliant. This was the record when everyone noticed.

The National's top 5 Cincinnati records: Morphine - Cure For The Pain

5. Morphine – Cure For Pain

Although they’re not from Cincinnati, I saw them at a laundromat bar there called Sudsey Malone’s when this record came out. Not many people were there, and after the show, Mark Sandman was selling the record out of a box from the stage and he seemed pissed. A dude in front of me bought the record for five dollars and when I got up there I gave him a 20 and waited for my change. He looked right at me and said “What?! For you it’s 20.” That actually made sense to me and it was worth it.

Keep Digging

Want to join the Discogs Community of music lovers?
Sign up for an account and subscribe to our newsletters for music articles, contests, limited-edition vinyl, and more.
Return to Discogs Blog

Why leave a comment when you can join a conversation?

Comments are not available for this post, but the forum is a great place to share your thoughts and exchange ideas with the Discogs Community.

Join the conversation, or start a new thread in the Discogs forum.

You can learn more about why we’re no longer hosting comments on our blog in this post.